Taylor Bicht
2 min read • August 13, 2024
Posted in
(Update 8/14 - The Minnesota Vikings confirmed J.J. McCarthy underwent surgery that required a full repair of his right meniscus and he will miss the entire 2024 season.)
Vikings rookie quarterback JJ McCarthy is facing knee surgery that could sideline him indefinitely, with his season potentially in jeopardy depending on the type of meniscus surgery he undergoes. Dr. David Chao, a former NFL team physician of 17+ years, explains that the outcome hinges on whether McCarthy's meniscus tear is amenable to repair or simply trimming. If the meniscus can be repaired through sutures, the recovery timeline extends significantly, potentially ending McCarthy's rookie season. However, if the tear can only be trimmed, McCarthy could return to the field within four to six weeks.
The difference between trimming and repairing the meniscus is crucial. Trimming the meniscus is akin to mowing the lawn, allowing a player to resume activities relatively quickly. In contrast, repairing the meniscus involves sewing and requires a longer recovery period, similar to waiting for new grass to take root. For McCarthy, this distinction could mean the difference between a brief absence and a season-ending injury.
Despite the short-term setback, Dr. Chao suggests that a longer recovery might not be detrimental to McCarthy's long-term development. He cites examples of successful quarterbacks like Jordan Love and Aaron Rodgers, who benefited from having time to learn and acclimate to the NFL before being thrust into starting roles. This time off could provide McCarthy with the opportunity to absorb NFL offenses and adjust to the league's demands.
Ultimately, while McCarthy's immediate future in the 2024 season is uncertain, the decision on his surgery will prioritize his long-term health and career. Whether he undergoes a meniscus trim or a full repair, the Vikings and their medical team will consider what's best for McCarthy's future in the NFL.
Ensure you have a FREE Sports Injury Central account and the 2024 NFL Preseason Injury Guide will be sent to you via email from Saturday 10 August. Look out for our newsletter sent from updates@sicscore.com
Later this month the guide will cost $49.99 so get set up now and take advantage of our leading injury data and analysis.
Don't have an account -
INSIDER INJURY KNOWLEDGE FROM FORMER PRO SPORTS TEAM DOCTORS TO GIVE YOU A WINNING EDGE IN SPORTS BETTING!
SIC PICKS are powered by the proven SIC Score algorithms from our exclusive panel of former Pro Sports Team doctors to give you a sports betting edge. Each day our team of doctors analyze the players and teams and share their expert insights to help you make informed bets on the biggest unknown to sportsbooks and sports bettors - player health and injuries!
Written by Taylor Bicht
